Skip to content

Welcome to Rider's Choice!

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Our Brands
    • Return Policy
  • Custom Horse & Rider Gear
  • For The Rider
    • Apparel & Footwear
    • Accessories
    • Riding Helmets and Safety Gear
  • For the Horse
    • Horse Blankets & Sheets
    • Supplements & Healthcare
    • Stable Supplies
  • Saddles & Tack
    • English Saddles & Tack
    • Western Saddles & Tack
    • Pre-Loved Saddles
  • Custom Team Apparel
    • Get Started!- Custom Team Apparel
    • Fox View Equestrian
    • Carousel Farm LLC
    • East End Equestrian
    • Midnight Moonchip Stables LLC
  • Gifts for Equestrians
  • Contact Us!
Log in
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
Riders Choice Supply Co
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Our Brands
    • Return Policy
  • Custom Horse & Rider Gear
  • For The Rider
    • Apparel & Footwear
    • Accessories
    • Riding Helmets and Safety Gear
  • For the Horse
    • Horse Blankets & Sheets
    • Supplements & Healthcare
    • Stable Supplies
  • Saddles & Tack
    • English Saddles & Tack
    • Western Saddles & Tack
    • Pre-Loved Saddles
  • Custom Team Apparel
    • Get Started!- Custom Team Apparel
    • Fox View Equestrian
    • Carousel Farm LLC
    • East End Equestrian
    • Midnight Moonchip Stables LLC
  • Gifts for Equestrians
  • Contact Us!
Log in Cart

Item added to your cart

View cart

Collections

  • RWR No Knot Hairnet - Elastic No-Knot Hairnets for Secure, Comfortable Hold - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Accessories

    Accessories

  • Dreamers & Schemers Pair and a Spare Boot Socks - ADULT One Size - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Apparel

    Apparel

  • Rider' Choice Supply Co Gift Card - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Bestsellers

    Bestsellers

  • Horse Amour Bit Wipes- Peppermint - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Bits

    Bits

  • Custom Horse & Rider Gear

    Create a look that’s uniquely yours. Our Custom Horse & Rider Gear...

    Custom Horse & Rider Gear

  • 5/A Baker® Classic Dog Blanket - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Dog Apparel & Gifts

    Dog Apparel & Gifts

  • English Saddles & Tack

    English Saddles & Tack

    English Saddles & Tack

  • Rider' Choice Supply Co Gift Card - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Equestrian Gifts & Jewelry

    Equestrian Gifts & Jewelry

  • ABSORBINE Veterinary Liniment Gel, 12 oz - Riders Choice Supply Co

    First Aid

    First Aid

  • HorseLoversHeel Lifters - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Footwear

    Footwear

  • Gifts for Equestrians – Perfect Presents for Horse Lovers

    Looking for the perfect gift for the rider in your life? Our...

  • Horsemen's Pride Jolly Hay Ball 11" H x 8" Blue - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Hay Feeders & Farm Supplies

    Hay Feeders & Farm Supplies

  • 5/A Baker® Medium Weight Turnout Blanket 200 Gram 82 Inches - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Horse Blankets & Sheets

    Horse Blankets & Sheets

  • Horse Boots & Leg Protection

    Horse Boots & Leg Protection

  • Horse Amour Bit Wipes- Peppermint - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Horse Care & Grooming Supplies

    Horse Care & Grooming Supplies

  • 5/A Baker® Signature Leather Halter - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Horse Halters & Lead Ropes

    Horse Halters & Lead Ropes

  • Horse Leads & Training Aids

    Horse Leads & Training Aids

  • Kiwi Express Shine Black Sponge Shoe Polish 0.23 Oz - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Leather & Boot Care

    Leather & Boot Care

  • Pre Loved Saddles

    Our Pre-Loved Saddle Collection features quality saddles available on consignment. Each saddle...

  • Pre- Loved Consignment Saddles

  • Roeckl Winter Riding Gloves Grip, Size 9 - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Riding Gloves & Belts

    Riding Gloves & Belts

  • OVATION Deluxe Schooler Helmet — Classic School Riding Helmet by OVATION for Equestrian Use - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Riding Helmets and Safety Gear

    Protect what matters most with our expertly curated collection of riding helmets...

    Riding Helmets and Safety Gear

  • The Original Rider’s Choice Custom Brass Stall Plate – Personalized Horse Stall Plate with Engraved Horse Portrait - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Stable Supplies

    Stable Supplies

  • 3M Vetrap Bandaging Tape 4" x 5 Yards (15') - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Supplements & Healthcare

    Supplements & Healthcare

  • Treats

    Treats

  • Nunn Finer Simichrome Metal Polish, 50gm Multicolor - Riders Choice Supply Co

    Western Saddles & Tack

    Western Saddles & Tack

Visit us

Rider's Choice Supply Co

2982 Veterans Memorial Highway

Bohemia, New York 11716

United States

631-471-5050

jaclyn@riderschoice.co

Tuesday - Saturday 10:30 AM - 5:30 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM -4:00 PM

Subscribe & Stay with us

Be the first to know about new collections and exclusive offers.

Secure payments

Your payment information is processed securely

Rider's Favorite

Recommended for all riders.

24/7 support

Contact us 24 hours a day, 7 days a week

Shop

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Custom Horse & Rider Gear
  • For The Rider
  • For the Horse
  • Saddles & Tack
  • Custom Team Apparel
  • Gifts for Equestrians
  • Contact Us!

Customer's Support

  • Track Order
  • Shipping Policy
  • Return Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us!

About Rider's Choice!

Hi, I’m Jaclyn, and I’m honored to welcome you to the new Riders Choice.

Horses have been a part of my life from the very beginning. I grew up surrounded by my grandparents, Joe and Millie, who both worked at the racetrack. My grandfather, Joe, showed me what it meant to dedicate yourself to the sport—he taught me about grit, loyalty, and the unshakable bond between horse and rider.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
Payment methods
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
© 2026, Riders Choice Supply Co Powered by Shopify
  • Privacy policy
  • Refund policy
  • Terms of service
  • Shipping policy
  • Contact information
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Opens in a new window.